Core Objection Points (Customise & Submit)

1. Drainage & Flood Risk (Plan is Unsound: Inconsistent with National Policy & Not Justified)

Unresolved Objections

The previous planning application for the site was refused following unresolved objections from the Lead Local Flood Authority (LLFA). The LLFA's concerns included drainage levels, attenuation, runoff calculations, gravity drainage arrangements and potential effects on St Helen's Wood. The previous planning application was subject to extensive technical scrutiny over a prolonged period, yet drainage concerns raised by the Lead Local Flood Authority remained unresolved at the point of refusal. This suggests that the site's drainage constraints are substantive and should not be assumed capable of straightforward resolution.

Premature Allocation

The allocation is not supported by a clear drainage feasibility assessment. The technical review concludes that the evidence reviewed does not contain an integrated appraisal of drainage destinations, site levels, SuDS requirements, land take and hydrological constraints sufficient to explain why development of this scale is realistic.

Lack of Baseline Evidence

The Council has acknowledged that St Helen's Wood is hydrologically sensitive, but there is no clear evidence explaining how development would avoid harm. The Local Plan itself recognises sensitivity to changes in runoff and groundwater conditions, yet there appears to be no verified baseline assessment of the site's hydrological relationship with the woodland and ghyll system.

Premature Allocation

The allocation relies heavily on future studies rather than evidence available at plan-making stage. The growing number of policy requirements relating to SuDS, groundwater monitoring, water quality, contamination pathways and sensitive receptors suggests that important questions remain unanswered. Residents may consider that these issues should be understood before land is allocated rather than being left to a future planning application.

Add your local example:

[e.g. Describe any surface water run-off, saturated ground, or standing water you regularly see on nearby roads or gardens during heavy rain, e.g., "During heavy downpours, I frequently witness significant surface water pooling along..."]

2. Ecology & Wildlife Loss (Plan is Unsound: Inconsistent with National Policy)

Direct Harm

Ecological concerns were sufficiently serious to contribute to refusal of the previous planning application, demonstrating that the environmental impacts remain unresolved. This was despite a lengthy consideration period, with plenty of opportunity to address ecological constraints and issues. The environmental impacts therefore cannot be assumed to be readily capable of resolution. • The allocation would cause significant harm to the ecological value of St Helen's Wood, including habitat loss, increased disturbance and fragmentation of habitats.

Severed Wildlife Corridor

The development would substantially reduce the effectiveness of the wildlife corridor linking St Helen's Wood with the wider countryside, harming ecological connectivity.

Off-Site Avoidance

The allocation relies heavily on off-site biodiversity compensation rather than avoiding or minimising harm at source.

Add your own example:

[e.g. List wildlife, birds, or bats you observe using this land, or describe how you use the adjacent nature reserves paths, e.g., "I regularly observe bats/badgers foraging across this boundary...", "We use this greenspace and enjoy ...."]

3. Deliverability and Housing Capacity (Plan is Unsound: Not Effective)

Unrealistic Capacity

The allocated capacity of at least 95 dwellings appears unrealistic given the site's numerous constraints and mitigation requirements. The site promoter's own recent planning application proposed only 65 dwellings, significantly below the capacity assumed by the Local Plan.

Progressive Reductions

The Council has progressively reduced the site's anticipated capacity since earlier consultation stages, indicating increasing recognition of development constraints.

Insufficient Evidence

There is insufficient evidence that the site can accommodate the allocated housing numbers whilst simultaneously complying with ecological, drainage, landscape and other policy requirements.

Add your local example:

[e.g. Mention local steep topography, utilities capacity or busy access roads that make intensive development look unworkable from street level.]

4. Unviable Affordable Housing (Plan is Unsound: Not Effective)

Broken Targets:

The Local Plan assumes delivery of 40% affordable housing; however, the promoter's recent planning application proposed only 25% affordable housing, raising concerns about viability and deliverability.

Abnormal Infrastructure Costs

The growing number of mitigation and infrastructure requirements is likely to increase development costs and further undermine prospects of delivering policy-compliant affordable housing.

5. Accessibility & Car Reliance (Plan is Unsound: Inconsistent with National Policy)

Car Dominance :

The site's location and topography are likely to result in a high degree of private car dependency compared with more sustainable alternatives.

Poor Location :

The site is not a highly accessible location in relation to services, facilities and public transport.

Add your local example:

[Note your experience walking or cycling locally, or the infrequency of the buses/distance of the nearest train station e.g., "Walking up from the nearest train station or shops is steep and impractical for elderly residents or parents with prams..."]

6. Evidence Base and Suitability

The Regulation 19 allocation contains a significantly expanded list of site-specific requirements compared with the Regulation 18 version, indicating increasing recognition of substantial site constraints.

Many of the key environmental, technical and infrastructure issues have been deferred to future planning application stages rather than being resolved through the evidence supporting the allocation.

The allocation has therefore not been demonstrated to be fully justified, effective or deliverable in accordance with the tests of soundness.

7. Site Ownership

The site allocation warrants particularly robust scrutiny given the Borough and County Council's landownership interests. Residents are concerned that significant ecological, drainage and deliverability concerns remain unresolved despite the Council's direct involvement in promoting the site.